Home/Episodes/Kait Steinbicker

EPISODE 012 · PSYCHOLOGY → CFO

Kait Steinbicker on being the calm one, and why hiding it doesn’t help anyone

Women [In]…™ · Season 1, Episode 12 · Releases Friday 4 December 2026 · 26 minutes
Hosted by Sondra Connor

Kait Steinbicker, guest on episode 12 of the Women [In]… podcast

Kait Steinbicker studied research psychology and business at the same time, which everyone told her was an odd combination. At twenty-three she moved from Canada to Arizona on her own. She has since been a finance leader in venture-backed software, taken an advertising agency through an exit, turned around the company that bought it, and advised a portfolio of founders. She describes herself as a builder, and when something is built, she looks around and asks what is next.

What you will learn

  • Why research psychology was the right degree for finance. It comes down to writing.
  • How she told a CEO no in her late twenties. And why he trusted it.
  • The case against “follow your passion.” What the early years are actually for.
  • Why calm is a credential, not a personality trait. Especially around founders.
  • The advice from senior women that stopped her. Their plan was to hide it.
  • What parental leave looks like when it isn’t a women’s issue. The Canadian version.

Was the psychology degree a detour?

No, and her answer is unusually specific about why. The research psychology programme taught her to take a topic and establish what the literature already said, what the drivers and correlations were, and which variables actually moved it. Things that look like common sense, she points out, still need research behind them when community organisations are applying for grant funding.

But the part she credits most is not the research. It is the writing.

“If you’ve written APA and journal articles, very clear, concise steps in how to convey a concept or theory or practice to whatever the audience might be.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

Sondra, who has taught, recognises the gap immediately: students want to tell you everything, and an executive has five minutes. Getting one, two or three things across cleanly is a strength that doesn’t get taught often enough.

What happened when she had to say no?

Her first role out of her MBA was at Parchment, a venture-backed software company, and they had just made a significant acquisition. In a product environment that produces a specific kind of question: go, or no go. Is this going to work?

She was asked for her assessment, and she gave it to the CEO directly. It was a no.

“It was a no, which is a hard spot to be in when you’re… late twenties. And he trusted that.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

She traces a straight line from that moment to how she still works.

“It’s served me my entire career, being very clear on your problem statement, your solution, or your conclusion.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

Why move countries at twenty-three?

She is honest that it was a shock. Arizona is very different, the US is very different, and it took her a few years to find her footing. What pulled her was not a city but a body of work: she wanted to be close to leadership as a discipline, and specifically to Ken Blanchard’s situational leadership, which she still finds practical rather than theoretical.

“Values, what different communities and countries value, really dictate how they structure different things.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

She is careful to date the decision. She graduated in 2009, and notes that the business community in Waterloo and Toronto has exploded since. The conversation she wanted to be in wasn’t happening near her at the time.

How does she pick the next job?

By what she will learn, and whether the environment is fast enough to be interesting. The through-line across venture-backed SaaS, an advertising agency, a boutique advisory firm and now CLA is founders; she has been around them her whole career.

The agency was the biggest build: she went in as the succession plan for two founders nearing retirement who had no exit plan, and came out the other side having done the merger, further acquisitions, the team rebuild and the ERP implementation. What she says drew her from the beginning is less glamorous and more useful.

“I was always looking for solutions to problems, whether it be, this is very manual, it takes a lot of time, we can do this better, let’s use a tool.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

Each move, in her telling, follows the same question: what have I not had the time or ability to learn, and what is my next step of growth?

Follow your passion, or follow what you are good at?

The second one. She says “follow your passion” never landed for her. She describes herself as an even person whose family cannot always tell whether she is ecstatic or the opposite. She remembers conversations with her sister, whose path fitted that advice better than hers ever did.

“Your job is to decipher what you like and don’t like, and what you’re really good at, and what types of environments you thrive in.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

That is what the early years are for, in her framing: not finding the thing, but gathering enough evidence to recognise it. And on the money question, which usually arrives attached to this debate, she is unbothered.

“If you’re leveraging your strengths and adding value, the money will come. I wouldn’t even focus on the money component, because that’s an outcome.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

“Master where you’re at and just keep on moving.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

What does it cost to be the calm one?

Sondra asks it directly, because Kait has run into guidance in consulting that didn’t fit her, and wondered whether that was because she is a woman, or because she stays level when other people don’t.

Kait does not treat calm as a temperament she happens to have. She treats it as an asset she knows the shape of.

“Knowing yourself is your first step to leadership, and leveraging those strengths in any situation.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

In founder environments, where a great deal comes up at speed, the pragmatic approach beats the urgent one. Her phrase for the role she plays is worth borrowing.

“I found it to be a way that I build trust and credibility, being that calm, stable, grounded advisor and resource for a client.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

She makes an argument for why this matters more now than it used to: with AI, fakes and general misinformation, decisions increasingly get made on the basis of who you trust and who has credibility with you. And where a client genuinely isn’t aligned with how she works, her conclusion is not that she should change.

“If they’re ultimately not aligned, then they need a different person to help them.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

What did the senior women tell her to do?

This is the hardest moment in the episode. In networking rooms where she was often the youngest person present, she had conversations with C-suite women about how to get the support they needed as working mothers. Their answer was to conceal it, and to have other women cover for them.

“That just struck me as, that’s not the way that we’re going to change and create change for the generations coming up below us.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

Her alternative is not performative. It is that women reaching those levels of leadership now get to influence how the next group is supported, and that this means being more bold about holding boundaries. Underneath it sits a redefinition she and her husband talk about often.

“Your value as you develop in your career is not in the hours that you work. It’s really in what you know and bring to the table as you’ve honed your skills and knowledge.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

She does not pretend this is easy, and says so: easier said than done, but it is how change happens.

What does she want for her daughter?

Having worked under both countries’ policies, she makes the comparison concretely. Parental leave in Canada has existed her entire life and is not framed as a women’s problem, twelve months at roughly eighty to a hundred percent pay, and she knows couples who split it six months each.

Her own choice was not to take long leaves with either child, and she is clear that she knew that about herself early. Which is exactly the point.

“It’s about having the choice and the option, and also the financial support to do so.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

A policy that recognises there are different makeups of who does what, as she puts it, stops the conversation being about women at all. On which she and Sondra agree: this is as much a male issue as a female one, and everybody has to move for it to change.

The one thing to do this week

“Jot down what you think you’re really good at and is a bright light for people, and follow that. Bring more of that to your day and your week.”

Kait Steinbicker, Women [In]… episode 12

Where to find Kait Steinbicker

Where to listen

This episode is not out yet. It releases on 4 December 2026. Follow the show on your podcast app to get it the day it drops.

Listen to Women [In]… episode 12 with Kait Steinbicker wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

Is a psychology degree useful in finance?

Kait Steinbicker studied research psychology alongside business and says it has been perfect rather than strange. The research training taught her how to establish what is actually driving a situation, and writing in APA format taught her to convey a concept in clear, concise steps for whatever audience is in front of her. She credits that writing discipline with her entire career.

How do you give a senior executive bad news early in your career?

In her late twenties at Parchment, after a large acquisition, Kait Steinbicker had to give the CEO a go or no-go assessment. Her answer was no. She kept it clear and concise and he trusted it. Her rule since: be very clear on your problem statement and your solution or conclusion, and tailor the message to the executive hearing it.

Should you follow your passion or follow what you are good at?

Kait Steinbicker never connected with follow your passion as advice. She prefers the version about leveraging what you are good at, and adds that the early part of a career is for deciphering what you like, what you do not, what you are genuinely good at and which environments you thrive in. On money, her position is that if you are leveraging your strengths and adding value, the money is an outcome rather than the target.

Is staying calm a disadvantage for women at work?

She has run into advice that assumed it was. Her view is that knowing yourself is the first step to leadership, and that being the calm, stable, grounded advisor is how she builds trust and credibility with founders in fast-paced environments. Where a client is not aligned with that style, she thinks they need a different person rather than a different Kait.

What should senior women do about the demands of parenting and career?

Not hide it. She describes conversations with C-suite women whose approach to the demands of motherhood was to conceal it and have other women cover for them, and says that is not how change happens for the generation coming up. Her alternative is holding boundaries and knowing your value, on the basis that your worth is in what you know and bring to the table, not the hours you work.

Who is Kait Steinbicker?

Kait Steinbicker is a Client Relationship Leader at CLA in Phoenix and a former CFO. She studied research psychology and business at Wilfrid Laurier in Canada, moved to Arizona for an MBA, and worked in venture-backed SaaS at Parchment before taking an advertising agency through an exit and the merger that followed, then advising a portfolio of founders at a boutique firm.